Starbeamrainbowlabs

Stardust
Blog


Archive


Mailing List Articles Atom Feed Comments Atom Feed Twitter Reddit Facebook

Tag Cloud

3d 3d printing account algorithms android announcement architecture archives arduino artificial intelligence artix assembly async audio automation backups bash batch blog bookmarklet booting bug hunting c sharp c++ challenge chrome os cluster code codepen coding conundrums coding conundrums evolved command line compilers compiling compression containerisation css dailyprogrammer data analysis debugging demystification distributed computing documentation downtime electronics email embedded systems encryption es6 features ethics event experiment external first impressions future game github github gist gitlab graphics hardware hardware meetup holiday holidays html html5 html5 canvas infrastructure interfaces internet interoperability io.js jabber jam javascript js bin labs learning library linux lora low level lua maintenance manjaro network networking nibriboard node.js operating systems own your code pepperminty wiki performance phd photos php pixelbot portable privacy problem solving programming problems projects prolog protocol protocols pseudo 3d python reddit redis reference releases rendering resource review rust searching secrets security series list server software sorting source code control statistics storage svg talks technical terminal textures thoughts three thing game three.js tool tutorial twitter ubuntu university update updates upgrade version control virtual reality virtualisation visual web website windows windows 10 xmpp xslt

NAS, Part 2: Assembly and Installation

Welcome back! This is part 2 of a series of posts about my new NAS (network attached storage) device I'm building. If you haven't read it yet, I recommend you go back and read part 1, in which I talk about the hardware I'm using.

Since the Fractal Design Node 804 case came first, I was able to install the parts into it as they arrived. First up was the motherboard (an ASUS PRIME B450M-A) and CPU (an AMD Athlon 3000G).

The motherboard was a pain. As I read, the middle panel of the case has some flex in it, so you've got to hold it in place with one hand we you're screwing the motherboard in. This in and of itself wasn't an issue at all, but the screws for the motherboard were really stiff. I think this was just the motherboard, but it was annoying.

Thankfully I managed it though, and then set to work installing the CPU. This went well - the CPU came with thermal paste on top already, so I didn't need to buy my own. The installation process for the stock CPU heatsink + fan was unfamiliar, which took me a moment to decipher how the mechanism worked.

Following this, I connected the front ports from the case up to the motherboard (consulting my motherboard's documentation showed me where I needed to plug these in - I remember this being something I struggled with when I last built an (old) PC when doing some IT technician work experience some years ago). The RAM - while a little stiff (to be expected) - went in fine too. I might buy another stick later if I run into memory pressure, but I thought a single 8GB stick would be a good place to start.

The case came with a dedicated fan controller board that has a high / medium / low switch on the back too, so I wired up the 3 included Noctua case fans to this instead of the slots on the motherboard. The CPU fan (nothing special yet - just the stock fan that came with the CPU) went into the motherboard though, as the fan controller didn't have room - and I thought that the motherboard would be better placed to control the speed of that one.

The inside of the 2 sides of the case.

(Above: The inside of the 2 sides of the case. Left: The 'hot' side, Right: The 'cold' side.)

The case is split into 2 sides: 1 for 'hot' components (e.g. the motherboard and CPU), and another for 'cold' components (e.g. the HDDs and PSU). Next up were the hard disks - so I mounted the SSD for the operating system to the base of the case in the 'hot' side, as the carriage in the cold side fits only 3.5 inch disks, and my SSD is a 2.5 inch disk. While this made the cabling slightly awkward, it all worked out in the end.

For the 3.5 inch HDDs (for data storage), I found I was unable to mount them with the included pieces of bracket metal that allow you to put screws into the bottom set of holes - as the screws wouldn't fit through the top holes. I just left the metal bracket pieces out and mounted the HDDs directly into the carriage, and it seems to have worked well so far.

The PSU was uneventful too. It fit nicely into the space provided, and the semi-modular nature of the cables provided helped tremendously to avoid a mess of cables all over the place as I could remove the cables I didn't need.

Finally, the DVD writer had some stiff screws, but it seemed to mount well enough (just a note: I've been having an issue I need to investigate with this DVD drive whereby I can't take a copy of a disk - e.g. the documentation CD that came with my motherboard - with dd, as it reports an IO error. I need to investigate this further, so more on that in a later post).

The installation of the DVD drive completed the assembly process. To start it up for the first time, I connected my new NAS to my television temporarily so that I could see the screen. The machine booted fine, and I dove straight into the BIOS.

The BIOS that comes with the ASUS motherboard I bought

(Above: The BIOS that comes with the ASUS motherboard, before the clock was set by Ubuntu Server 20.04 - which I had yet to install)

Unlike my new laptop, the BIOS that comes with the ASUS motherboard is positively delightful. It has all the features you'd need, laid out in a friendly interface. I observed some minor input lag, but considering this is a BIOS we're talking about here I can definitely overlook that. It even has an online update feature, where you can plug in an Ethernet cable and download + install BIOS updates from the Internet.

I tweaked a few settings here, and then rebooted into my flash drive - onto which I loaded an Ubuntu Server 20.04 ISO. It booted into this without complaint (unlike a certain laptop I'm rather unhappy with at the moment), and then I selected the appropriate ISO and got to work installing the operating system (want your own multiboot flash drive? I've blogged about that already! :D).

In the next post, I'm going to talk about the filesystem I ultimately chose. I'm also going to show and discuss some performance tests I ran using fio following this Ars Technica guide.

A comparison of compression formats for storing JSON

Happy new year, everyone!

I've blogged about different aspects of a (not so?) little project of mine several times now (exhibits A, B, C, D, and finally E - even if I didn't know it at the time), but it appears that I end up running into all sorts of interesting problems that I invent cool solutions for. I also find myself doing a bunch of research that I'm surprised nobody's compiled into a single place yet - as is the case in this blog post. (Also, Happy 2018 everyone! First post of the year :D)

I've been refactoring the subsystem that saves a considerable amount of JSON data to a bunch of different files on disk. Obviously, I'm interested in minimising the amount of space this JSON data takes up on disk. As this saving process happens in the background on a separate thread, I'm not too concerned about performance - other than it can't be too slow. With this in mind, I've found myself testing a bunch of different compression algorithms. Let's introduce our test data:

  1. A 17MiB card game dataset, as a single minified JSON file
  2. A 40KiB 'live' specimen chunk's data, saved as a single minified JSON file.

I can't remember which card game the first dataset is from, but I do know that I found it in the awesome JSON datasets list. Next up, here's our cast of compression algorithms we'll be testing:

  1. The venerable GZip
  2. BZip2 - Apparently GZIP, but smaller and slightly more computationally expensive
  3. XZ (the newer child of LZMA2)
  4. 7zip
  5. Google's Brotli

A colourful cast, to be sure! Let's run them through their paces - starting with the card game dataset. Here are the results I observe with each set to their default settings:

Format Size
Uncompressed 17M
gzip 2.4M
bzip2 1.6M
xz 1.3M
7zip 1.4M
brotli 1.3M

Very interesting. It looks like xz and brotli are tied in first place - though I observed that brotli took ages in comparison to all the other algorithms I tested - and upon closer inspection xz beat it by 17.3KiB. Numbers are all very well, but to really see what's going on here, let's plot it on a graph:

A graph of the data in the table above.

That's better! I can actually make some comparisons now. From this graph we can observe that gzip is the worst of the lot, followed by bzip2. 7zip is surprisingly in third place, but then again it is designed for multiple files, whereas the rest of them are designed for a single stream of data. In second place is the terribly slow brotli, and finally in first place is xz.

Hrm - very interesting. How do our algorithms measure up when confronted a smaller load though? Here are the results for the sample chunk data:

Format Size
Uncompressed 40K
gzip 5.4K
bzip2 4.3K
xz 4.6K
7zip 4.9K
Brotli 4.6K

Interesting results, to be sure, but I can't discern much from that. Let's plot a graph:

A graph of the data in the above table. Further explanation below.

Very interesting. With smaller loads, it appears that bzip2 performs much better with smaller loads than any other algorithm. While gzip is still the worst performing algorithm, while xz and brotli, surprisingly, performed much worse than bzip2.

To that end, I'm think I'm going to be choosing bzip2 as my compression of choice for this job, as it produces the best results for the type of work I'm going to be doing.

I'm really surprised about brotli though, actually. I had high hopes for it, considering it's a new algorithm invented by Google. They claimed that it would provide xz-like compression with gzip-like speeds - but from what I'm seeing, it does anything but.

Sources and Further Reading

Art by Mythdael